Or: Is there any place for ancient craftsmanship in modern engineering?Depending upon the part of the world you come from, there is an implicit assumption about whether or not an engineer uses tools. In some countries, it is assumed that it would be beneath an engineer, as a professional, to use tools. They are meant to be cerebral professionals. In some other countries, the word “engineer” is conflated with a number of different trades, and it is assumed engineers do little other than use tools. You will also find places that sit between these two extremes.
I am not going to have that debate here. You are an engineer, and you know what your specific role requires. Maybe you do use tools at times to do your work. I have been there. Maybe you work at a place where an engineer picking up a tool would cause a strike. I have been there too. Instead, I am going to talk about the benefits of knowing how to use tools and why there is indeed a place for craftsmanship in engineering. In a prior article, I mentioned the notion of the sensual engineer. The idea is that, by using all your senses, you can become better informed about any challenge you are facing and thus develop a better solution. When one has experience using tools, one can enhance the ability to imagine through multiple senses because making something provides sensory information about the object as it takes form. Not only that, when you know how to use tools, you can explore the solution space as you try different ideas through rapid prototyping. This also increases your understanding of the problem. You will recall, if you have read my book on global engineering, that this is coevolution, where solving the problem helps you better understand it. In earlier forms of engineering, the design of a solution often occurred as it was physically implemented. Read the excerpt below from Homer’s Odyssey. This is where Calypso is helping Odysseus build a raft. Note that, as Homer describes the act of making the raft, he also describes the design decisions being made. The passage depicts a form of engineering in which design and implementation occur together. She gave him a great axe, well fitted to his hands, an axe of bronze, sharpened on both sides; and in it was a beautiful handle of olive wood, securely fastened; and thereafter she gave him a polished adze. Then she led the way to the borders of the island where tall trees were standing, alder and poplar and fir, reaching to the skies, long dry and well-seasoned, which would float for him lightly. But when she had shewn him where the tall trees grew, Calypso, the beautiful goddess, returned homewards, but he fell to cutting timbers, and his work went forward apace. Twenty trees in all did he fell, and trimmed them with the axe; then he cunningly smoothed them all and made them straight to the line. Meanwhile Calypso, the beautiful goddess, brought him augers; and he bored all the pieces and fitted them to one another, and with pegs and morticings did he hammer it together. Wide as a man well-skilled in carpentry marks out the curve of the hull of a freight-ship, broad of beam, even so wide did Odysseus make his raft. And he set up the deck-beams, bolting them to the close-set ribs, and laboured on; and he finished the raft with long gunwales. In it he set a mast and a yard-arm, fitted to it, and furthermore made him a steering-oar, wherewith to steer. Then he fenced in the whole from stem to stern with willow withes to be a defence against the wave, and strewed much brush thereon. Meanwhile Calypso, the beautiful goddess, brought him cloth to make him a sail, and he fashioned that too with skill. And he made fast in the raft braces and halyards and sheets, and then with levers forced it down into the bright sea. Homer, The Odyssey, Book 5, lines 234–261, translated by A. T. Murray. I should note that Samuel C. Florman introduced me to the idea that this passage highlights both an early form of engineering and the sensual nature of the work in his book The Existential Pleasures of Engineering. Upon reading this text, can you sense the deep connection between the designer-engineer, Odysseus, and the vessel taking form because he is the one forming it? He sees the materials first-hand, so he can understand their suitability for the task. He understands that the tree trunks must be straightened so they can be fitted together. He can see where the mast and steering oar will sit as he constructs the vessel, and he can see the need to protect against the waves. Each action provides a better understanding of the challenge and what needs to be done. If Odysseus were later to draw up plans for another vessel, perhaps an improved one with features not yet tried, you could be sure that he would understand the nuances of its implementation: how it would be made, how it might fail if poorly made, which features would be difficult to make well, and what would be needed to implement it. Having had this experience, he would be a better engineer. This is, of course, from a very different time. So what does it mean for you? Today, you could not practically hope to have the skills and experience of all the craftspeople involved in executing most engineering tasks. Instead, experience using tools can provide additional, rather than complete, insight. It can also help you better understand the people you work with as you discuss the challenge and potential solutions. Experience and know-how with tools will improve your ability to understand both the challenge and the ideas put forward by others. That will make you a better engineer. So yes, engineers should know how to use tools. You should also continue developing your craftsmanship because the experience of making things will help you more fully explore the engineering challenges you face.
0 Comments
|
AuthorClint Steele is an expert in how engineering skills are influenced by your background and how you can enhance them once you understand yourself. He has written a book on the - The Global Engineer - and this blog delves further into the topic. Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|
RSS Feed